‘Recipe for tragedy’: Aus expert’s Tesla fear

Deals of the Week 5:39AMTuesday, November 11th, 2025 In the know quiz Set your local weather Breaking News Courts & Law Courts & Law Courts & Law Courts & Law South Australia Western Australia Northern Territory Breaking News North America US Politics South America Middle East UK Politics Health Problems Mental Health Inspiration Weight Loss School Life Restaurants & Bars Food Warnings Relationships The Sealed Section Family & Friends Fashion Shows Fashion Trends Face & Body Cosmetic Surgery True Stories Lifestyle Videos Travel Ideas Short Breaks Food & Drinks Destinations North America New Zealand Middle East Central America South America Travel Advice Tips & Tricks Accommodation Australian Holidays Northern Territory South Australia Western Australia Travel Videos Entertainment Celebrity Life Hook Ups & Break ups Celebrity Photos Celebrity Kids Celebrity Deaths Celebrity Style What To Watch Morning Shows Current Affairs Upcoming Movies Movies Reviews Music Festivals Books & Magazines Golden Globes Entertainment Videos Social Media Mobile Phones Home Entertainment Archaeology Environment Climate Change Sustainability Natural Wonders Motoring News On the Road Technology Videos Cost of Living How to Save Salary Secrets Personal Finance Superannuation Australian Culture Power & Influence Inside Parliament Gig Economy Breaking News Manufacturing Other Industries Australian Economy World Economy Interest Rates Federal Budget Australian Markets World Markets Australian Dollar Cryptocurrency Real Estate Sydney & NSW Melbourne & VIC Adelaide & SA Cricket Live Scores V8 Supercars Sports Life American Sports Paralympics Horse Racing Expert Opinion More Sports Sport Videos Sales & Deals Home & Appliances Health & Wellbeing Motoring News ‘Recipe for tragedy’: government adviser warns about Tesla’s FSD An Aussie motoring expert has delivered a grim assessment of Tesla’s newest and much-hyped piece of car technology. Danielle Collis November 11, 2025 - 11:19AMMotoring Share via Email Share on Facebook Share on Whatsapp Listen to this article Copied URL to clipboard Tesla owners furious with Elon Musk's FSD promises Broken promises surrounding Tesla's Full Self-Driving claims have upset the company's fan base, as James Chung reports. When Tesla flicked the switch on its Full Self-Driving FSD (Supervised) technology in September, Australians became the first right-hand-drive market in the world to get the controversial feature. But experts warn the system is “dangerously misleading” and unregulated, putting lives at risk. Car Mechanical Services CEO, Co-founder and long-time government safety adviser Raffy Sgroi said Tesla’s branding gives drivers a false sense of security. “The term ‘Full Self-Driving’ is dangerously misleading,” she said. MORE: Tesla enables full self driving in Australia Co-Founder and CEO of Car Mechanical Services Raffy Sgroi. Picture: Supplied “Despite its name, this system is not autonomous. It requires constant driver supervision, hands on the wheel, and eyes on the road. Yet the branding encourages a false sense of security, one that directly contradicts the system’s actual capabilities.” At midnight on September 18, Tesla rolled out FSD (Supervised) across Australia and New Zealand, with more than 50,000 local owners having access to the latest technology. The over-the-air update allows the cars to steer, brake, change lanes merge, and navigate intersections and roundabouts with minimal driver input, but under Australian law, the driver must remain fully attentive at all times. Australia is one of just a handful of countries, Elon Musk’s Tesla has rolled out FSD in. RELATED: Elon Musk responds to Aussie journo Ms Sgroi has spent more than two decades advising government on regulatory compliance, says Tesla’s approach is unlike anything she has seen before and that Australia has effectively allowed an unfinished technology to operate without oversight. ‘STARK DISCONNECT’ “In my 20-plus years advising governments on safety protocols and regulatory compliance, I have never seen such a stark disconnect between a product’s name and its functional reality,,” she said. She compared the tech industry’s “move fast, and break things” attitude to “a recipe for tragedy” when applied to public roads. Copied URL to clipboard Tesla finally enables full self driving in Australia Elon Musk’s Tesla has just dropped a huge... Tesla insists the technology remains a level 2 advanced driver-assistance system, not an autonomous one. “Drivers must maintain proper control of the vehicle at all times,” the company said in its Australian release. Ms Sgroi said Tesla’s global approach to development, learning through the live driver data, means Australians are effectively participating in an experiment every time they turn it on. “What troubles me deeply is that Tesla has effectively turned public roads into a testing laboratory. Every FSD-equipped vehicle is collecting data, learning, and yes, making mistakes,” she said. MORE: Tesla’s Full Self-Driving puts Aussies at risk Reporter Danielle Collis testing Tesla's Full Self Driving (Supervised). Picture: Supplied “But these are not mistakes made on closed courses with professional safety drivers. These are errors happening at 110 km/h on highways, in school zones, and at busy intersections, often where families are simply trying to get to work or school.” She said the system’s braking and automation capabilities risk “automation complacency”, where drivers trust the car too much and become distracted. “Here’s what concerns me most: we are deploying beta-level technology that fundamentally misunderstands human psychology,” she said. Ms Sgroi believes the rollout is especially risky because the system was trained primarily on American roads. “Australia’s right-hand drive configuration introduces an entirely different set of variables. Our roundabouts, unique intersection designs, and road signage conventions differ substantially from the environments where this system received most of its training data,” she said. “I’ve seen first-hand how systems optimised for one market can fail catastrophically in another without proper adaptation.” MORE: Tesla faces class action over Full Self-Driving failures Tesla has tested "Full Self Driving" in Australia. Picture: Supplied Adding to this, Ms Sgroi said that under current laws, if a crash occurs while using FSD, the driver remains responsible, which leaves drivers vulnerable. WHO IS RESPONSIBLE? “When an FSD-enabled Tesla crashes in Australia, who is responsible? The driver who was told to remain vigilant but was lulled into complacency by the system’s name? The company that pushed an unfinished product to public roads? The state government which licenses drivers? The federal government that approved vehicle imports?,” she said. “This legal and ethical grey zone is unprecedented in automotive history.” The federal government is currently drafting an Automated Vehicle Safety Law, expected to come into effect in 2026, which will establish national standards for automated driving systems. However, Ms Sgroi said “it’s taking too much time to develop the National framework adequately” and that the Federal government isn’t listening to industry-based insights. “It needs to be developed before goals are formally announced (as is currently the case),” she said. Reporter Danielle Collis testing Tesla's Full Self Driving (Supervised). Picture: Supplied Ms Sgroi supports the development of autonomous vehicles but said Australia must not confuse innovation with readiness. More Coverage China’s ‘perverse dumping’ in Aus ‘ignored’ Danielle Collis, James Chung Massive changes to Aus’ favourite ute Matt Campbell “Innovation has saved countless lives over my career, from airbags to electronic stability control but importantly, each advance was carefully tested, validated, and adapted for Australian conditions before deployment,” she said. “The current approach to FSD is recklessness dressed as innovation. Australia is allowing deployment of technology not adequately trained for local conditions, on a road network unlike that used for development, with wildlife and weather hazards unique to our country, and essentially no regulatory framework to ensure public safety. We are gambling with lives.” Tesla has been approached for comment. Originally published as ‘Recipe for tragedy’: government adviser warns about Tesla’s FSD Join the conversation (5 Comments) Add your comment to this story To join the conversation, please log in. Don't have an account? Join the conversation, you are commenting as More related stories On the Road Massive changes to Aus’ favourite ute Australia’s favourite car is undergoing some huge changes that drivers have waited almost a decade for. Motoring News China’s ‘perverse dumping’ in Aus ‘ignored’ The Aussie government is being accused of ignoring potential national security and environment risks posed by China’s ‘perverse dumping’ Down Under. Motoring News Aussie car boss warns of industry ‘collapse’ One of Australia’s leading automotive figures says the industry will face a ‘reckoning’ with a wave of ‘consolidation and collapse’ coming for major brands. Registration In The Know Quiz Newsletters Competitions Welcome to news.com.au Code of Conduct Help and Support General Feedback Advertise with us Standards of Practice Licensing & Reprints Our News Network The Daily Telegraph The Courier Mail Our Partners realestate.com.au CODE Sports A NOTE ABOUT RELEVANT ADVERTISING: We collect information about the content (including ads) you use across this site and use it to make both advertising and content more relevant to you on our network and other sites. Find out more about our policy and your choices, including how to opt-out.Sometimes our articles will try to help you find the right product at the right price. We may receive payment from third parties for publishing this content or when you make a purchase through the links on our sites. Privacy policy Relevant ads opt-out Cookie policy Terms of use Nationwide News Pty Ltd © 2025. All times AEDT (GMT +11). Powered by WordPress.com VIP Oops An Error has occurred {"isTrusted":true} More stories before you go