Chicago Cubs advised to target Baltimore Orioles star in anticipation of 2026 catcher shakeup

The 27-year-old Rutschman had a dip in productivity last season, posting a .220 batting average and .673 OPS with just 9 home runs. Prior to 2025, though, the switch-hitter delivered 20 home runs and 19 home runs in 2023 and 2024, respectively. He’s also considered a strong defensive player and a smart pitch caller. Rutschman has two more years of team control, earning about the same $5.5 million salary as Kelly right now. Would the Cubs be willing to move on from what was a strength in 2025, even if the writing on the wall seems to indicate that the catching crew is due for a downturn? Would the Orioles’ asking price be too steep? Could the Cubs be convinced of Rutschman’s health and durability? Would the goal in acquiring Rutschman be the acquisition of DH insurance rather than a starting catcher as Seiya Suzuki likely moves back to right field? Add these questions to the many more facing the Cubs this offseason.